CFB Fantasy — Week Recap
Commissioner’s Notes
First week of the playoffs and first playoff upset. Jacob’s luck turns around and carries him to a week win and a trip to the semis. We’ll have a brief summary of the PVP matchups this week and a preview of next week.

Note: there’s some images I had Claude make that didn’t go into the writeup available in the Supplementary Information page
Choke Job of the Week
This is a 1a/1b situation. South Carolina gets the slight edge for having a slightly bigger loss as a slightly bigger favorite, but James Madison was close behind. These are doubly impactful because the top 3 players overall played both; these games cost the collective 126 points vs the spread. South Carolina’s loss was particularly bad when you consider what it does to the resumes of two playoff contenders in Alabama (neuters their biggest win) and Tennessee (damages what was a quality loss).
Wild Card Round Recap
Dylan vs Jacob
This matchup is a rematch of the week 10 placement game. It featured the best ATS luck of the week in Jacob at +110.8, and Dylan’s -98 ATS luck is only 1.2 points better than Bob’s for worst. That swing is more than their 181-point differential. Oddly, these two players over the past 2 weeks have had similar ATS luck (Dylan -56.8, Jacob -32.7), but the order cost Jacob a PVP win last week, which held him in the three-way tie with Bruce and Dan, which he lost on tiebreakers. If the order of this week and last week had been reversed, Jacob’s win would move him into 4th, changing the wild-card round matchups to Bruce vs Dylan and Dan vs Jacob, which in turn would have flipped the playoff race, with Dan and Dylan moving on to the semifinals rather than the consolation game.

Dan vs Bruce
This matchup was a lot closer, but there was still a big gap in luck. Bruce was +72.2 ATS while Dan was -27, and likewise that differential was bigger than the score differential of 71. Dan jumped out to a huge early lead, but his schedule was front-loaded early in the day. By about 7 pm, the gap had nearly closed and they traded runs until about 11, at which point Bruce took the lead and expanded it to the end of games.

Semifinals
This week we will see the semifinals plus Dylan and Dan for the 5/6 consolation game. I’ll preview this week’s playoff matchups. Below, I’ll list each matchup’s previous PVP results, the non-matchup record of how they would have matched up in the other 9 weeks, and the teams they shared. Each of the 3 matchups is cross-pod, so many of these matchups will share several teams.
Semifinal 1: Zach vs Bruce
- Actual record: Zach swept 2-0, +249 differential
- Non-matchup record: Zach leads 6-3, +727 differential
- Shared teams: BYU, Buffalo, LSU, Louisiana Tech, Washington State
Zach has been the luckiest player in PVP matchups, but has a better overall record over the season; Bruce has the highest week-to-week volatility, and that massive swing in performances could be the difference.
Semifinal 2: Bob vs Jacob
- Actual record: split 1-1, Bob has a +71 differential
- Non-matchup record: Bob leads 5-4, +620 differential
- Shared teams: Central Michigan, Delaware, East Carolina, Iowa, Northwestern, Pittsburgh, South Florida, Toledo, Tulane, Wyoming
This matchup pairs the unluckiest players in the PVP placement matches. Bob has the clear edge over the course of the season, being top in total points and 2nd in match play, but Jacob’s week win in this most recent week rights his ship. Over the last two weeks, Jacob has had the worst spread luck of the week followed by the best spread luck of the week, both by large margins.
Consolation Game: Dan vs Dylan
- Actual record: Dylan swept 2-0, +186 differential
- Non-matchup record: Dylan leads 8-1, +494 differential
- Shared teams: Alabama, Florida State, Kentucky, Louisiana, Oklahoma State, Ole Miss, UCLA, Wisconsin
Dylan outscored Dan in the first 10 weeks of the season, with Dan’s only hypothetical win coming this last week. Based on previous weeks, Dylan seems to be the favorite, but as this week shows, bad or good luck could decide the outcome.
Match Play Scenarios
While the playoffs are still going on, we still have a race for the match play lead. After this most recent week, Jacob has more match play points than Bruce’s or Dan’s max, so the top 4 and bottom 2 diverge. Dylan is favored vs the field to win the top spot, but none of the top 4 are mathematically eliminated, even Jacob after this week’s result.

Pod vs. Pod —
Overall Results
This Week’s Matchups
| Player | Pts | Pts | Player |
|---|
Season Leaderboard
| Rk | Player | Match Pts | Total Pts | PVP Record |
|---|
Player Detail
Max — Best Possible Lineup, Any FBS Team
Unplayed Games
Redundant — scored on the bench, but no slot could use them
| Team | Conf | Net | Owner | Pod |
|---|
Wasted — a bench team that could have been swapped in
| Team | Conf | Pts Gained | Instead Of | Owner | Pod |
|---|
Top Unowned Scores (League-Wide)
| Team | Conf | Net | Free Agent In |
|---|
Games by Pod & Ownership
Pick Similarity
Cross-Pod — Same Teams Picked
Which teams two players both picked this week, regardless of the slot each used. Same-pod players can’t share a team.
Ranked by matching teams
| Pair | Matching | Shared Impact | Shared Teams |
|---|
Ranked by shared impact (Σ |margin|)
| Pair | Shared Impact | Matching | Shared Teams |
|---|
Every Pair — Points Per Slot
Slot for slot, how close were the points? Conference slots pair by conference; the flex slots pair best-to-best by margin. Lower distance = more alike. Same-direction slots are where both picks won, both lost, or both hit zero.
| Pair | Slot Pt Distance | Same-Direction Slots |
|---|